Brett Gelman

Clarinet Player

Self - Murray Bauman

Milton

Terry

Gideon Van Der Koy

Gabe

Willy

Mr. Fields

Alistair Grumps

Dr. Sylvester

Magic Myc (voice)

Gary Pimbladt

Marcellus (voice)

Victor Rykov

Marcellus (voice)

Egg (voice)

Self

Bruce

Bobby (voice)

Self

Self - Panelist

Self

Narrator

George

Frank Lerue

Col Thomas Wentworth Higginson

Rick Ramsey

Big Man

Self

Carl Lemay

Roland Finkelstein

Robert

Vogelsein

Acting Teacher (uncredited)

Brady Thompson

Paul Revere

Isaac

Jeff

Greg

Martin

Murray

Himself

Dr. Greg Colter

Self - Guest

Shaman

Hamish

Howie

Stuart

Himself

Dusty Nugget

Demon

Self

AJ

Watch

Himself

Mr. Pilaf

Mr. Mozer (voice)

Jeff (voice)

Goker

Brett Mobley

Self

Jeff Raskin

Art Thief

Joseph Pulitzer

Tom

Brett Gelman

Ivan

Self

Mr. K

Carlos

Dog Lawyer

Self

Mr. Celebrity

T.V. Director

Brett Gelman

Pizza Boss

Carl

August

Brett Mobley

Hal

Gavin

Bachelor Party Host

Doug (voice)

Hot Rod Johnson

Annoying Hipster

Daniel

Glenn

The Magician

Hammer Throwing Man (voice)

Gay Man (voice)

Mervyn (voice)

CIA Agent (voice)

Candy Cane Eater (voice)

Truck Driver (voice)

Mayhem Team Member

Wise man from the east

Rocket Horse (voice)

Pig Parker

Escape Room Guy (voice)

Supervisor Burns